דר' מרב שניצר | כפיית יחסי מין ב" נישואי קטנות", דיון במקורות ההלכתיים של אשכנז במאות ה-12- 13

  • Published on
    29-Jul-2015

  • View
    538

  • Download
    7

Embed Size (px)

Transcript

' , " , : ( ) 21 31: . : ' ' . , . : , , : .

" " - 21 - 31

1 -21 31 "",2 21 , . , 7, , 3 " , . 4 , 5

. , , , , . " ', " , , ". , , ' 17. 2 "" 21 . 21 21 "" 21 . , " , , ' , ", , : (, 3002), ' 301. . 3 , , ": " " ( ) " 4 , " ' " . , " (, "), ' 34, . " ", ".5

1

.6 , 8

7 .

, " " . " " . . , 21 31, . . 9 , . , - 21 31, . " " , 01

01 41 21 31. 11

: , " " ' ( ), ' ":" ... ' ... ... " ' " : " ... " 7 , , ": " ... ", , , , , : "... ". 8 , , ' 17 78, ' 57: " , ' ", " "" Mordechai A. Friedman, "The Ethics of Medieval Jewish Marriage", in Religion in a Religious Age ed. S. D. Goitein (Cambridge, 1974), p.86: "Giving child brides into marriage was also practiced by the jews of Europe.", Kenneth R. Stow, "The Jewish Family in the Rhineland in the High Middle Ages: Form and Function", pp. 1101 1102, Judith R. Baskin, "Jewish .201.Women in the Middle Ages", p " 31", , 54 (), ' 801 - 901. , : , " ", : , , ( , 0791), ' 191 791, , " ", , ", , ( , 7991), ' 01 51, , , ' 201 601. , , , 61( , 6991), ' 23 33. 01 , , ' 57. 11 , : " ", " " " , , -0411 5221, , , , 31, ". - , " ". .9

6

, , .21 , ? 1. , . 31 - 21 31, , ( " 11) 41 , 21, . . 51 . " " ( ) ()".61 . , , . " (, 11), . " : " " ",71 ? " (, 31), , " 21

Mordechai A. Friedman, "The Ethics of Medieval Jewish Marriage", in Religion in a .4791 ,Religious Age ed. S. D. Goitein, Cambridge , , , , ,. 02 41 . ' 09 19. 31 . 41 Michael J. Broyde, Michael Ausubel ed.,Marriage, Sex, and Family, London, Boulder .131 031 .(New York, Toronto, Oxford, 2005), pp 51 , , ' 951- 561, 434 844, , " ", , (, 5991), ' 511, 611 021. 61 , , (, "), " " . (0901 0711 ) " , .71

. ": " ... ... ... " 81 . . ", : " " ' ".91 21 31, , , , , . , . , ? ( ), .02

.

, , , 12

. 31. ,

. ( 21) . 22 51, " , " " ( ), . 91 , ". " , " ", , , (8891), ' 911 021. 02 . 12 21 31, . : Angeliki E. Laiou, "Introduction", in Consent and Coercion to Sex and Marriage in Ancient and .Medieval Societies, p. vii 311 .Ruth Mazo Karras, Sexuality in Medieval Europe, p , :22 81

: " 32

" ".

21 , 21 , ( ). , 21, . 42 . 52

. .

, , , , ? ? ? "" . "": , . , 21 , . , 62 11 , , 21 , 72

.

"". ", 21 . 31. ": " ,042 832 ,532 .James A Brundage , Law, Sex and Christian Society in Medieval Europe, pp ,257, 335, 357, 433 - 434, Christopher N.L. Brooke, The Medieval Idea of Marriage (Oxford 1989), pp. 128 133, 137 138, 274, James A. Schultz, " Medieval Adolescence: The Claims of history and the Silence of German Narrative", Speculum, 66:3 (1991), p. 528, Dyan ,Elliott, "Marriage", Medieval Women's Writing, ed. Carolyn Dinshaw and David Wallace :2003, pp. 40 42, 43, Michael M. Sheehan, "Choice of Marriage Partner in the Middle Ages Development and Mode of application of a Theory of Marriage", Studies in Medieval and ,"Renaissance History, 1:(1978), pp. 9, 13 17, 31, John T. Noonan, "Power to Choose Viator, 4 (1973), pp.427 430, McCarthy Conor, Love Sex and Marriage in the Middle Ages (London, 2003), pp. 16 19, Charles Donahue, Law, Marriage and Society in the Later .02 .Middle Age: Arguments about Marriage in Five Courts (Cambridge, 2007), p 32 " " , '. 42 . 52 K. Gravdal, "Chretien de Troyes, Gratian, and the Medieval Romance of Sexual .865 -565 .Violence", pp 62 , , ". 72 , ". 21 .

" ".82 : " ' " " " 92

".

, " , " " . " ( ") " " ..." [ ..] " "03 , ": " 13

" ".

21 . , .23

( ).

, . : ", , ", " , , , (, "), " , " ", ' , " ?", : , , , (, "), ' 93 94. ' "" " ", , , , 2002, ' 711. 92 , , , " , " . 03 , ", , , . " , , ", ' , . 23 . , ", ": " , " " " : , , , ":" ... , " "", . . : ", , " : " . ", " " ( ) ": "... ". " " ( ) : " ". , , , ": " ( , 21) , " :" " , , , ": " '... ' " () [] [] ' ' ". . , 81. . 13 82

" " (, , )33 , . . 43

.

" " , . 53 ,63 . :"... : 73

".

. "" - 11 . . . , . 83 . .93

" , .

.481 381 .Israel Abrahams, Jewish Life in the Middle Ages (London, 1932), pp 33 , ". " , , 21 . , , : 21 21 21 . " . 43 , " ( ' )", ' " (" "), ' ", , ' 601 801. 53 , , , ": " ", : ' , " ", : , , , , , (, 0991), ' 351 371. 63 , , 571 , , 008 , . , ". 83 , , , (, 8591), ' 33- 73, , , ' 88- 19. 93 , , , , , ' 691.73

04

.

( 8 01) . , 14 . : " , , , . 24

, : , ". "34

: " " , "44

. '".

. 01 . , 11, , ( 8301), .

, " ", ' - , , ' 76 86. 14 , (, "), ' : " ' ' ' ' ", ' : " ",' ": " ", ' : " ". , : , ( , 2691), , 4, ' 43, : " : , . , ". 24 , ' : " ' ..." , ' , :" ... ' ... ...", , , , 4, ' 13. 34 ( 9), , " , , ", , ' . " " . , (, 1002 ), . , , ' 76 86: " " " ", , "". ' 76. , ' . ' . ' : " ". . . 44 " (569 5501, , ), , ' , .

04

11 , , , 54 64

( 11, ).

11, " ( , , 069- 0301) " ( , 0401 - 5011) . . . 11, 74

.

01 11 , . . 84 94 , " ". 05 . , "" 15

"".

: , , , , (, "), ' 831: "... " ' "" , , ":" " [ ] ..." , , " "", ( , "), ' 31: " , , ". 64 , : , , , , 5991, ' 37: " [ ] ' ' , ... , ", " ." 74 ' , (, 2991), ' 31 41. 84 "" " , ", , , ' 12. : " ... , " , , (, 2002), ' 42. 94 , , (, 8991), ' 351. 05 , , ' 01. 15 , ": (, 6002), ' 44- 74, , , ' 31.

54

2. . 01 11. . 25 " " , : " " , ".35 , , . " " . " . " , . " . : " , "45 : " ." " . "55

, , : " " : " " "

01 11 , , : .872.Irving Agus A., The Heroic Age of Franco German Jewry (New York, 1969), p : Irving A. Agus, Urban Civilization in Pre Crusade Europe, vol. 2 (New 896 .York, 196), p - 01 11 21 31. 01 11. " ( , 74). 01 - 11, , ' 17 18, . 35 696. Irving Agus, Urban Civilization in Pre Crusade Europe, p , ( , "), ' , . , , , ( , "), ' " , (, "), , ". 45 , " " " , (, "), ' 16 36. 55 ' 36: " () ' "..

25

" 65

.

" , 75 ( , " 31) " : "... " [ ] "85 " . " , ( ' 0011- 1711 ) " (' , 5121 3921).95 " ". . 06 ( ) " . , , . 16 " , 41 51. 21 31 " ". 41. 41 , : , : "

" , , : " " " . 75 " " " ", , , ", , , , '. ( , 41 ' ' . 21 31, " , , 0521 - 7231 ) 85 , , ", . 95 " , , ". ( ) " " . () , , . " ( ). : , , ", , , , , . 16 , ", ' 44. " . " , . ' (). " .06

65

, ,

26

."

. . " ( , 51) . . " " "36 " ".46 . , .56 ", 66

51, " .

- 61 , , ": "" " ' , ' "76 " 11 , " . " " . " ". . " ( , 0901- 0711). ", , . " : ", , , , , ". ' . .26

" " , . 46 . 56 . 66 ", " ", ' 53 63, 89 76 , " " , (, 0791), " " , (, , 61). 21 31 . . " "" ().

36

, , , 86

. , . , : " , , 96

"

, , . , , " , , . , . . . . , , : " - , , 07

".

, , . ( 21 31), "... 17

' " ..."

" , , ", ", " , " " . 96 , , ", " " ... " " : " , . " 07 , ", " " ." 17 , , . ", , .

86

"" "".27 ' 31, : " 37

... ".

, , , , " , , "47 . . , . . , " ."57 : " ' , .67

"

: "... ".77 " " ( ) : " ". ,

" 0491 ,)Parma De Rossi 189 (Parma Pal 7921, ' 79 , , "" "", . ( " , ) " 7921, , "" 14 . )Neubauer 877 ( Oxford, Bodleian, MS, Mich 9921, "". : .043 .(Neubauer 875) Oxford Bodleian, MS, Opp

27

, , ' , : " : ' ". 47 " " . , , ' 17. 67 " , . " " ( ) ".

37

57

77

, , . 87 , . , . : , . , . " () ... " " " 97

" ".

, "... " ",08 . , . , , 31, , : "... 18

".

, ( 21) " ( 31) , , . 28 " , , ", ,

, , , 4291, ' 982-092, . 97 , , . 08 , , . 18 , , ' . 28 "" "" , . ". " , : ". , " ", ' 691.

87

. : " " ... ... "38 " " ( ) 48

, , , .

" , , : "... , ...".58 " . , ", " " (, , , "), , 68 " , " ".78 , " " , , , . " . " ( , , - 21): " " " ".88 " : ' , , ":

", ", , , , ". 48 " (" " ") ". , . , ": " " ( " , " . ) " " . " ' , , .58

38

: , " ": " " 78 , . 88 , . , ". " .

68

"" 98

".

": " ' (" ") , 41, 09

"

( 21 31), : " ' " "19 " ."29 " : " 39

, ."

, , , , . . : " "49 , , :" 59

."

21 31 " ", . . , , , . 09 , . 19 , ' , . " " , ". 29 , , 39. , . 39 " , , (, "), , ' . " " , , , " ' ", ", ", " , , . 49 ", ( ), ". 59 .98

, , . . 11, , ", , 11 , , " ( , 8311 4021) , , : " ".69 : , ": "... , 79

: . ...".

. . ? ?

3. - . . , , 89

.

", , , (, "), ". 79 . " : , , ' , " " , , , 31, : " " " 89 ", : " ". , . : ? . : . .

69

. " " : " , ." , . 99 , , 001 . 101

. .

, . . : " 301

",201 "'. "

. 401 . , . . , . . , : " ' 501

".

. 001 " ... , " ". , . " " ( ), " " (, )

99

, , ' 334. "" . 201 , , ". 301 , , ". , , , ", , ". . 501 , , ' , : , , , ": " , ". , " :" ... " " ". ": " , ... ". " , '. : " " ":" 401

101

, , , , " ".601 . . " ", "" ....