Критерии качества научного журнала

  • Published on
    04-Apr-2017

  • View
    216

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Transcript

  • . .

    16 (20) 2010

    I z v E S t I APENzENSkOGO GOSudArStvENNOGO

    PEdAGOGIChESkOGO uNIvErSItEtAimeni v. G. bELINSkOGO

    PubLIC SCIENCES

    16 (20) 2010

    025.17

    . . -

    - ,

    e-mail: ivan.kotliarov@mail.ru

    . . // . . . . 2010. 16 (20). . 715. , . . . . . - . - . - . : , , .

    kotliarov I. d. Criteria of the quality of a scientific journal // Izv. Penz. gos. pedagog. univ. im.i v. G. belinskogo. 2010. 16 (20). P. 715. the article contains an analysis of the method of evaluation of scientific journals used by the Higher Committee of Certification as well as an analysis of the index of integration of scientific journal in the system of scientific communications, proposed by the Vernadsky National Library of Ukraine. A new method of calculation of index of journals scientific quality is developed on the basis of these two methods. A method of prevention of compensation is proposed. the problem of publication fee is analyzed and a possibility of its solution is described. An algorithm of application of the index of journals scientific quality to the analysis of scientific output is proposed.Key words: quality of scientific journal, index of journals scientific quality, publication fee.

    ( , , . .) . - - .

    - - ( , , ). , , , - ( , -), - -. , -

    - , .

    , (, , - ) ( - ) (- - ). - - , , , - . - -- .

    - -, , , -

  • . . . 16 (20) 2010 .

    , . -, , :

    - -, ;

    - , , , - , .

    - - -, . , - . , - .

    ,

    , -

    () (, ) , - [4]:

    . -

    - web of Science, Scopus, web of Knowledge, astrophysics, PubMed, Mathematics, Chemical abstracts, Springer, agris.

    .

    ( , - ) :

    1. ( - ). - - ;

    2. . - . , , - , - ;

    3. ;

    4. - ;

    5. -, ;

    6. . 2- ;

    7. , - ;

    8. ;9. -

    ;10. -

    ;11. -

    ;12. ISSn;13. -

    / / ( ). - .

    , , . . , , .

    , , , -, - - , .

    , , , - :

    1. (. . ), , , - ;

    2. -, ;

    3. , (, - ). (, - ), ;

    , - , . . , , , - . , , , , - , .

  • . .

    - , . . . - , - . . - ( [1]). , - (, ,

    ). , -, - , - .

    , , , - . , , - - .

    . 1.

    1 [1]

    /

    1

    10 1

    10 0

    2 4 1

    4- 0

    3 ISSn - ISSn

    1

    4 (, . .), , - , , ,

    1

    . . 0

    5 (-)

    1

    () 0

    6 1

    7

    1

    8 -

    Scopus, ISI web of Knowledge, Inspec, MeDlIne . .

    1

    9

    . .

    1

    10 - - 07.07.2008 436/311

    - 07.07.2008 436/311 - - . .

    1

    . 10 ( , [1]). - 4 . - , , 4 [1].

    , -

    , :

    1. :

    , , - (, . 7 8), , -, , - (. 45);

  • 10

    . . . 16 (20) 2010 .

    ( - ) (. 45). , - -. , , , , ;

    , - (, ), .

    2. , . . , - ;

    3. , - . , 3 - , 5 . , ( , ) .

    , - () , - , -, - , .

    :

    - - ;

    - - ;

    - , . - ;

    - , . - ( - ). .

    , - , - , , , .

    (. 2).

    45, , -

    30. , - 66% , .

    . 2:1. -

    ISSn, - . - , , , web of Science;

    2. - . - , elsevier, Springer wiley-Blackwell, - ( ). - , , - , ;

    3. , , , ( );

    4. , , , - . - - - (, );

    5. , , , - ;

    6. - - ;

    7. - : - ;

    8. - - - , , - ( , - - ) .

  • 11

    2

    1 2 3 4 5

    1

    0 1

    1

    2

    2

    0 3

    ,

    1

    - , , -

    2

    ( ) -

    3

    4

    3 - -

    -

    0 1

    -

    1

    ( , - )

    2

    3

    4

    4

    0 2

    , 1

    , 2

    6 ( - )

    0 1

    1

    2

    7 - ( - )

    ( - )

    0 1

    -

    1

    2

    8

    0 3

    1

    2

    3

    (. . - , )

    4

    9

    0 2

    1

    2

  • 12

    . . . 16 (20) 2010 .

    1 2 3 4 5

    10

    0 3

    1

    2

    ,

    3

    ,

    4

    11

    , -

    0 2

    - 40% ( )

    1

    40%

    2

    --

    3

    12 0 2

    1

    2

    - -

    3

    13 - -

    , -

    0 2

    , -

    1

    25% -- , . .

    2

    , 25%, -, , . .

    3

    14

    , 0 1

    , -

    1

    , -

    2

    15

    0 1

    / 1

    / 2

    16

    -

    0 2

    1

    2

    17

    (. . - ; )

    0 3

    ,

    1

    -

    2

    -

    3

    (- , , , - , )

    4

  • 13

    . 2, , - - , - .

    - -. , [2]. .

    , - - . , , , , - . - , . - , - .

    , - , . , , - , . - , - , , , , , .

    - , - . - :

    ( , ); - ; . . ,

    , . , ,

    , - , , -

    . - , -, . . , . , ( , -, , ) , , - . , , , - . .

    , - , -. -, , .

    - ( - , ):

    1. , ( ). - - -, - . - ;

    2. :

    - ;

    ( - );

    ( - ; , , ). , . , - - , , . - ;

    ( );

  • 14

    . . . 16 (20) 2010 .

    3. , - - , , - . (, - - ), ( , - , , -). ;

    4. - ;

    5. : ; ;6.

    (- . 5), (- , -) (- );

    7. - - ( - ). , , .

    , - - (, , , ).

    - (. 2), , .

    - :

    1. , - - . , , - . , , , -

    , - , , , ( , - ), . - , -, , . , , - ;

    2. - , - () . [3] (, ) , . , , - . , (), - , , . 26, 40, , 33 ( - - ), , 231 . -, (40), - , - , . , - , - , .

    , - .

    , -

    - ( ), - -, - .

    , . , - , - , .

  • 15

    , , , -, .

    1. (- 2009 .). : http://www.nbuv.gov.ua/portal/ink.html. 23.01.2010.

    2. , -

    - . : http://vak.ed.gov.ru/ru/list/infletter-29-06-2009/. 23.01.2010.

    3. . - 194 29.03.2002. : http://vak.ed.gov.ru/ru/docs/?id4=153&i4=19. 20.04.2009.

    4. . - 74 30.01.2002. -: http://vak.ed.gov.ru/ru/docs/?id4=155&i4=4. - 07.02.2010.

Recommended

View more >