ВСЕ ЛИ ОБЪЕКТЫ И ВЕСЬ ЛИ ПРЕДМЕТ КРИМИНАЛИСТИЧЕСКОГО ПОЗНАНИЯ ЛЕЖАТ В СФЕРЕ ПРАВОВЫХ ЯВЛЕНИЙ: СРАВНЕНИЕ С НАУКОЙ УГОЛОВНОГО ПРАВА

  • Published on
    06-Apr-2017

  • View
    215

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Transcript

  • 343.98.343.2.7 (477)

    . . ,

    . .

    .

    :

    . . ,

    ,

    .

    - ; ,

    (, ) .

    , , ,

    , , , -

    ( ), .

    : , , , ',

    ().

    ,

    , 1952 ., 90-

    . . . , . . , . . ,

    . . . 1987 . ,

    , ,

    , [4, . 26].

    . 1994 .

    : [6, . 696].

    [5, . 5-13].

    - -

    , , ,

    , , [5, . 5-13].

    , ,

    . . [.: 2, . 37-40; 6, . 696-701] 5

    :

    1) ' ;

    2) ,

    ;

    3) , , ,

    , ;

    4) ' , ,

    , , , ;

    5) , - ,

    .

    , , , ,

    :

    [6, . 703].

    (. . [14, . 20-24]), (. . [12,

    . 10], . . [10, . 8-10]), . . , .

    ,

    . . . . .

    , , ,

    [.: 11; 19].

  • , ,

    . . . .

    [20]. 5-

    , , . ,

    . . , . .

    .

    ,

    ' . ,

    . . ,

    .

    , [6, . 697].

    . . , , '

    . ,

    , .

    .

    , ,

    , '

    [20, . 14].

    , ,

    , . . . .

    , ,

    , () '

    , () , ()

    ' , [3, . 75].

    . . :

    , .

    , ,

    , .

    [20, . 15].

    , ,

    - ,

    ( ). ,

    .

    . . : , ,

    , [6, . 697], , ,

    , . ,

    ,

    - . ,

    - .

    : 2 ,

    ?

    ,

    , [.: 1, . 33; 13,. 46; 15;

    18, . 38]. , , , ,

    . ,

    ( , ) (

    , , ) . , ,

    , ,

    , .

    , , ,

    . , , '

    ,

    , - ,

    ' () ' () .

    ,

    , , . ,

    ,

    , .

  • . , -

    , ( ,

    , ,

    . :

    (, ) ), ,

    , ' , , .

    , ' ( - ) ,

    . -

    (, ) .

    , ,

    . ,

    , - - ' (),

    , . ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    , ,

    , ( ),

    , , , (', ', '

    ' ) : ( ) -

    . . , , , -

    (de lege lata)

    , (de lege ferenda),

    ,

    . ,

    .

    ,

    - ,

    .

    , . ,

    ,

    , ?!

    ,

    ( ) -

    , .

    - , :

    ; ; , ; ,

    .

    , ' ,

    , ,

    , , . ,

    -

    ( ), ,

    ,

    .

    ' ' ,

    ? ( )

    . . . ,

    .

    , . . , , ,

    , , - ,

    - ,

    , ,

    , .

    , , '. ( ),

    , - .

    ,

  • , , .

    . , . . ,

    (, , )

    [16,

    . 113], , ,

    , () (

    ) .

    ,

    ,

    , , , ,

    . ()

    , , , .

    , , , -

    ( ), ,

    , , .

    (, ),

    -

    , , ,

    delegeferenda .

    , ()

    () ,

    .

    ' .

    , . . . 227 (

    ) . VII ,

    . XIII , ,

    , ,

    . ,

    , . 227 ,

    , .

    .

    , ,

    .

    , ,

    . , (

    ) -

    - . ,

    - , ,

    [9, . 12].

    , ,

    () ,

    ( ), .

    , :

    ,

    ,

    , - .

    , , ,

    [.: 7; 8; 17, . 87]);

    , ,

    . , - ,

    ' , ;

    , - ,

    , ( ),

    ;

  • - ( ),

    ,

    , ;

    , -

    , ,

    . , ,

    , .

    ,

    , . , ,

    -

    . ,

    .

    , :

    .

    : 1. . . : / . . , . . , . . , . . ; . . . . .: -, 2002. 990 . 2. . . :

    : . / . . . .: , 2001. 240 . 3. . . : [ 3- . . 1:

    ] / . . . .: , 1997. 408 . 4. . . : , , . : . / . . .: . ., 1987. 272 . 5. . . / . . //

    . . . ., 1996. . 513. 6. . . . ( . 2001 .)

    // . . . .: , 2009 . 687703. 7. . . / . . , . . // . . 2005. . 3 (15). 8. . .

    : - : . / . . , . . . .: . . .,

    2002. 251 . 9. . . ( ): . . . . . . : 12.00.08 / . . . ., 2003. 21 . 10. . .

    : / . . . .: , 2008. 888 . 11. : . .

    (, , 27-28 . 2008 . .: . 2008. 503 . 12. : . / . . . . [4-., . .] . : , 2008. 728 . 13. : . / . . . . [2- ]. .: , 2001. 544 .

    14. : / . . . , . . . [2- . . .]. .: -. 2009.

    944 . 15. . . : . ... -. . / . .-, 1997. 337 . 16. . . : . .: .

    .. . .: ..., 2001 352 . 17. . . :

    / . . // . 2011. 2. . 84-93. 18. . . : . [ 2- . . 1]. .: , , 1999. 416 . 19. . . : -

    : . / . . . .: , 2009. 231 . 20. . .

    , / . . // 2011 2. . 8-23.

    :

    . .

    . . ,

    ,

    .

    ; , (,

    ) .

    , , ,

    , ,

    , ( ),

    .

    : ; , ;

    , ().

    DO ALL OBJECTS AND ALL BODY OF FORENSIC KNOWLEDGE LIE IN THE AREA OF LEGAL

    PHENOMENA: A COMPARISON WITH THE CRIMINAL LAW SCIENCE

    Kaluzhna O. M.

    The article analyzes and disproves the thesis of R. S. Byelkin that not all patterns of crime mechanism and

    the mechanism of trace evidence lie in the area of legal phenomena, and hence this proves non-legal nature of

  • criminology. Scientific concept of "crime" and "mechanism of the crime" are compared in terms of their suitability

    for the study of any human activity, the universality of the causal connection, social (political, ideological) nature of

    social conditionality of criminalization or decriminalization is stated. Therefore criminology, as well as criminal law

    and science, exploring the phenomena of objective right or related phenomena, actually produce knowledge about

    universal phenomena. And vice versa any phenomenon may become a legal phenomenon, in the literal sense, as

    soon as it gets objectified (consolidated) in the law.

    Key words: mechanism of the crime; mechanism of trace evidence; crime subject; causal relationship, the

    social conditioning of criminalization (decriminalization) of certain activities.

    12.03.2012 .

Recommended

View more >