Shmeiwseis- Eisagwgh Sto Dikaio

  • Published on
    22-Oct-2015

  • View
    35

  • Download
    15

DESCRIPTION

- . .

Transcript

  • 1

    .

    pi , pi ,

    pipi , Europa-Institut, Universitt des Saarlandes

    pi

    2013

  • 2

  • 3

    , " " , ,

    ( pi pi pi ). pi , ,

    pi

    pi pi

    .. . 1983, pi, , pi pi

    (pi pi ). , pi

    pi , pipipi pi

    pi .

    2012-2013, pi " pi ",

    pi. pi , ,

    pi ,

    pipi .

    pi pi pi pi.

    pi , , ( pi pipi pi ) pi pi ( pi pi) . pipi, pi ( ) , pi pi , pi ,

    pi pi pi

    pi .

    :

    () pi ,

    pi

    ,

    pi pi .

    pi pi

    (1983) ( pi pi ), - - verbatim pi pi pi , 30 , pi ( - italics).

  • 4

    , , pi

    pi

    pi

    , pi

    pi , ,

    pi, .

    , 2013, pi .

  • 5

    :

    -

    1. 2. 2.1 pi 2.2 2.2.1 2.2.2 : pi pipi

    2.3 2.4 pi 2.5 3. 3.1 pi 3.2 3.3 pi 3.4 3.5 pi

    :

    1. pi 2. pi, pi, pi

    2.1 pi 2.2 pi

  • 6

    2.3 pi 2.4 2.4.1 pi 2.4.2 pi 3. : 3.1 pi pi 3.2 O fora pi

    3.3

    4.

    :

    1. 2. 2.1 pi 2.2 pi 2.3 2.4 3. 3.1 pi 3.2 pi ( 14 )

    3.3 pi ( 15 ) 3.4 ( 16 ) 3.5 pipi ( 17 ) 3.6 ( 19 ) 3.7 pi pi 4. pi 4.1 pi 4.2 pi ( 289)

  • 7

    4.3 pi ( 290 ) 4.4 pi ( 291 ) 4.5 ( 292 ) 4.6 5. 6. :

    6.1 pi 6.2 pipi Delors 6.2.1 pi 6.2.2 pi pi 6.3 pi 6.3.1 pi 6.3.2 pi pi pi pi

    6.4 6.4.1 6.4.2 6.5

    ()

  • 8

  • 9

    :

    -

  • 10

  • 11

    1. () pi ( ) pi pipi ( ), pipi pi, pipi , .

    , pi

    , pi .

    pi pi pi

    pi , :

    pi ,

    .

    pi (1983), . 47-48, ( ): "(...) pi pi pi , pi

    , pi .

    :

    . pi

    , pi , pi

    , pipi pi ,

    pi pi ,

    pi,

    .

    pi , pi pipi ,

    , pi ,

    pi pi

    .

    pi

    pi pi o , pi

    (pi . ) : pi, pi, ."

    pi pi :

    pi pi (' ) pi/ ( ),

    , pi pi ,

    pi ( ). pi Excursus 1.

  • 12

    ,

    , pi pi pi:

    (pi , pi 2), (pi 3), (pi , pi 2

    3), ( , pi 4).

    () pi pi , pi (pi pi ).

    2 3

    2 3 4

  • 13

    Excursus 1: ( (1983), . 49-53.)

    . pi

    pi .

    pi pi , ,

    , pi

    pi pi ,

    pi . pi

    pi pi

    . ,

    , pipi pi

    pi pi, pi

    pi. pi pi pi ,

    pi pi pi pi

    pi pi

    , pi pi pi pi pi

    pi pi , pi

    pi pi pi

    pi, pi pi pi. ,

    pi pi pi

    . pi pi

    pi 13 pi , pi. ..

    pipi Lenin pi Koursky pi pi pi , pi pi 1934 pi Nikolai pi .

    , pipi

    pi .

    pi , pi

    pi

    , pi pi pi. pi pi

    (Liberalismus)

    . pi ,

    pi, , ,

    pi , .

    (pi ) pi pi pi pi

    pi , pi pi

    (pi. pi) . pipi , pi pi

  • 14

    ,

    , pi pi pi

    , pi pipi pi pi .

    pi pi

    , pi pipi

    pi (...), pi pipi .

    : , pi pi

    .

    II. pi pi , pi , pi

    1904. pi : . ,

    . ,

    . (imperium), . pi.

    pi , , pi. pi

    pipi pi ,

    pi pipi pi

    , .

    , pi

    pi, pi ,

    , pi

    . ., 417, pi pi , pi , pi

    , pi

    .

    , pi pi, . , pi pi

    pi pi '

    (ius cogens), pipi , pi pi pi pi

    (ius dispositivum) , pipi . pi,

    pi , o pi ,

    pi pi. , pi pipi 1825 pi., pi pi a ( 1829), , o pi

    . pi , pi

    , pi pi. pi , pi

    pi pi ( 42).

  • 15

    . ' , pipi

    pi ,

    pi pi , pi pi

    . , pipi ,

    pi , ,

    pi pipi ( ) pi . pi. pi

    , pi , pi pi,

    pi .

    pi pi. pi

    , pi pipi, pi . pi

    pi ,

    pi , pi pipi,

    pi , pi

    , pi .

    , pi . pi pi.

    pi pi pi , pi pi

    pipi ( pipi ) pipi, pi .

    , pi pi pipi,

    , pipi . , pi.

    pi pi,

    , pi '

    pi, .

    ,

    , pi ,

    .

    . pi pi

    ,

    pi, pi pi pi.

    pipi ,

    . pi , pi pi

    pi

    pi, pi pi

    , . . pipi ,

    pi

    pi, pi

    pipi pi pi pi,

    pi pi pi pi

    , pi pi .

  • 16

    Excursus 2: ( (1983), . 68-70)

    . pi, pi

    pi, pi pi , pi

    . pi ,

    pi pi pi pi

    pi , pi

    pi

    . M pipi pi , pi pi

    pi pi pi .

    pi .

    II. pi pi , pi pi

    . pi ,

    pi pi

    . pi

    pi .

    . pi , pi

    , pi pi pi.

    pi , , pi

    ,

    pi pi pipi

    , pi, pi pi

    pi pi ,

    pi pi ( ) pi pi, pi pipi

    pi ( ). . ,

    pi, pi pi pi,

    , pi pi .

    , pi pi pi pi,

    pi pi , , pi

    ' ,

    . pipi, pi pi

    pi, , pi ,

    .

  • 17

    III. pi . pi , pi pi pi pi, pi

    pi , pi pi ,

    pipi pipi pi.

    , pi pi , pi

    pi pi pi .

  • 18

    2. 2.1 pi To ( " ") pi

    . pi , pi, :

    pi pi pi

    , pi

    pi ,

    pi pi , pi

    pi , pi pi

    pipi pi pi

    .

    (4) : (pi , pi 2.2), (pi 2.3), pi (pi 2.4), (pi 2.5).

    2.2 2.2.1 pi ( pi) . ,

    pi:

    pi pi , pi

    pi pi

    ,

    pi

    pi .

    ,

    pi pi , pipi

    , , pi ,

    pi . , pi,

    pi :

    ,

    ,

  • 19

    pi ,

    pi pipi,

    pi pi ( ).

    2.2.2 : pi pipi

    , pi () 27 2008 . pi (4) , :

    () (" ", 1-3), , :

    pi, pi

    ,

    pi pi pi ( pi pi),

    (pi , , pi ) pi ,

    pi.

    () (" ", 4-25) , pi, :

    ,

    pi pipi,

    pi,

    ,

    pi pipi ,

    ,

    ,

    pi,

    pi ,

    pi ,

    pi pi.

  • 20

    () (" ", 26-105), pi , (6) :

    (, ), pi, , pi

    ,

    - , :

    ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    .

    () , (" ", 106-120) pi pi :

    ,

    pi ,

    pi ,

    .

    2.3 .

    pi

    ( pi pi , pi , pi ), pi (pi ), pi pi (pi, pi pi ) pi ( ). () pi pi :

    ,

    pi ,

    , pi ,

    , pipi .

    () pi : pi,

    ,

  • 21

    pipi pi pi ( , pi ),

    pipi pi pi

    , pi ( pi pi pi).

    pi (1983), .56, pi- ,

    , , pi pipi pi

    pi ,

    .

    2.4 pi pi . pi

    pi , pi :

    pi pi pi pi ( pi pi ) pi pi pi pi ,

    ,

    pi pi pi pipi

    .

    pi pi, pi pi pi :

    pi.

    , pi, pi

    pi:

    () pi pi pi: pipi pi pi

    ( " pi"), pipi pi pi pi

    pipi ( " pi"). () pi :

    pi ( pi pi pipi), pi, ,

    pi .

    () , : pi pi pi (pi..,

    pi , pi

    ),

  • 22

    pi pi pi (pi.., pi ).

    2.5 .

    pi pi

    pi ,

    ,

    , pipi, pi

    pi.

    pi (1983), . 58: " pi pi

    . ,

    pi pi, ,

    pi . pi

    , pi pi

    pi, pi pi pi pi

    pi

    pi, pi pi

    . O pi , pi

    pipi pi pi

    pi."

    pi

    pi , pipi

    (3) : () , ( ) pi , pi pi pi

    ,

    , pi pipi

    .

    pi

    .

    () pi ( pi ) pi , pi:

    ,

    pi pi .

  • 23

    pi, pi,

    pi pi ,

    , pi pipi:

    pi pipi

    ,

    pi , pi

    pi

    .

    pipi pi .

    () , ( pi ) pi , pi pi pi

    , pi pipi pi

    .

    pi pi

    .

    pi (1983), . 61-62: " pi , pi

    pi pi , pi

    pi pi.

    , pi pi ,

    pipi pi. pi

    pi pi

    pi, , ,

    pipi, pi . pi

    pi pi, pi pi

    pipi , pi pi

    pi , pi pi

    ."

    3. 3.1 pi pi pi

    . pi

    , pi pi pi

    pi pipi pi.

    , ,

    pi pi pi pi

    , , pi

    pi, pipi

    pi.

  • 24

    , ,

    :

    (pi , pi 3.2), pi (pi 3.3), (pi 3.4), pi (pi 3.5).

    3.2 pi

    , pi pi pi

    pipi ( pipi, pi pi

    ) . pi pipi pi

    pipi.

    ( , pi pi 23 1946 pi pi ), pi pi :

    () pi , pi . ,

    , :

    pipi, ,

    pi pipi ,

    pi,

    pipi, pi, pi

    pi ,

    (pi pi ),

    , (pi pi ).

    () , pi " ", :

    pi pi pi

    ( ), , pi pipi

    pi pi (pi.., pi pi pi pi (pi) pi pi).

  • 25

    , :

    (i) pi pi pi pi pi pi

    , pi pi pi

    ( pi, pi ). (ii) (pi.., pi, , (pi , pi 3.4, ), , , pi, ), ( pi pi). () pi , pi pipi pi pi.

    pi , :

    pi ( ) pi ,

    pi pi,

    pi, pi, pi

    pi , :

    pi pi ( ), pipi pi (pi pipi),

    (pi ) pi (pi ), pi pi ( pi pipi).

    () , pi pi pi

    pi .

    :

    , pi (), ,

    ,

    ,

    pipi .

    () , pipi , pi pi pipi :

    ,

    ( ).

  • 26

    (1983), . 63-64: " pi

    , 18 pipi

    ,

    , pi pi pi

    , pi pi '

    pipi .

    pi pipi.

    , , pi

    19 , pi , pipi .

    pi pi pi

    (. ), pi pipi pi , pi

    .,

    ,

    , pi pi .

    , pi

    ."

    3.3 pi pi ,

    pi pi , pi

    pi pi pi pi

    pi pi pi pipi pi

    pi. pi pi pi , pi

    :1

    () pi pi pi pi pi

    pi , pi

    pi.

    1 pi pi ( pi) . - . (2011), . 57-59.

  • 27

    pi

    , pi pi,

    pi pi pipi pi , pi

    pi pi,

    pi (pi 1). pi , (pi . ) pi , pi pi pi pi

    pi pipi, pi pi pipi, pi

    , pi. pi pi pipi

    pi pi pi,

    pi.

    () pi -pi :

    (), pi (pi..,

    ). () pi pi pi pi pi pi pi pi

    . pi :

    pipi (pi.., ), ( ).

    () , pi pi pi pi

    pi,

    pi

    . pi :

    pi, ,

    ( pi ), ( "pipi

    ). () pi . pi pi pipi,

    pi , pi pi

    pi. :

    pi,

    pi ( ), pi pi.

  • 28

    pi , pi- () pi , pi pi pi pi pi pi

    pi ( ): pi (() pi ) pi (() ), / ( ).

    () pipi pi , , pi

    ( pi pi pi ). pi pi pi pi , , , (pi.., pi , pi ). () , pi pi pi pi pi , pi

    "" . pi pi

    pi.

    3.4 , pi

    pi , pi

    , pi pi

    pi. :

    () pi , pi

    ( pi pi ). () , pi , pi

    pi (). pi pi

    :

    pipi ,

    pipi (" "), pipi pi ("pi ").

  • 29

    3.5 pi pi

    . pi , pi

    pi pi

    pi . pi,

    pi pi pi pi:

    () pi " ", pi pi pipi , pi

    . pi

    pipi pi.

    () pipi, pi "pi ", . ,

    pi , , pi

    pi pi ( , 50). pi pi pi

    pi , pi , pi .

    pi pi pi pi

    pi

    , pi pi pi .

    , pi pi

    pi (1709). pi pi .

  • 30

  • 31

    :

  • 32

  • 33

    1. pi pi pi (pi /), pi pi: (pi , pi 2), pi

    (pi 3), (pi 4).

    2. pi, pi, pi

    2.1 pi pi

    pi , pi pi

    pi , , pi,

    . pi

    pi. pipi, , pi , pi pi pi :

    , , pi

    pi,

    , pi (), (pi Box), pi, pi

    pi (), pi pi, pi ,

    pipi ,

    de facto , (non-governmental organisations,

    NGOs). pi , pi pi

    pipi, (pi, pi.., ).

  • 34

    Box ( "") pi

    pi pipi

    . :

    () 1944, pi pi (Monetary and Financial Conference) , pi Bretton Woods New Hampshire . () (" "), pi 27 1945. () , pipi

    (, quota). pi , pi (Washington). () . ... pi pi

    pi pi pi

    pi pi pi

    ...,

    (pi.., pi). () pi. () , pi, : 1. (Board of Directors), 2. (Executive Board), 3. (Executive Director), 4. pipi (staff), 5. (Council), 6. pipi (Committee on the Interpretation of the Board of Governors) ( ).

  • 35

    2.2 pi pi 38, pi. 1, . pi :

    (pi , pi ), (pi ), pi (pi ).

    pipi,

    pi pi ,

    ( pi

    ). () pi, , pi pi . ( ) , pi , pi ( pi) . pi ,

    :

    ,

    pi pi pi ,

    ,

    pipi ,

    pi ,

    ,

    pi ,

    pi pi pi pi

    pi .

    () pi pi . pi:

    pi

    pi ( pi ), pipi pi

    .

    () pi, , pi .

    pi/, pi ( pi ) pi pi . pipi

    :

  • 36

    pi

    pipi,

    pi pi pi pi

    pi pi ,

    pi ,

    estoppel, pi pi pi pi ,

    pi pi pipi

    pi ,

    pi pi pipi

    pi pi ,

    pi pi

    ( pi (pi.., pi), pi pipi pi).

    2.3 pi pi pi ,

    :

    (pi , pi ), pi pi (pi ), pi (pi ), pi pi pi (pi ), pi pi pi

    pi pi (pi ), pi ,

    , pi

    pi,

    ,

    ,

    (pi , pi 3).

    () pi . pipi, pi (7) :

    pi pi ,

  • 37

    pi pi

    ,

    pi pi ,

    pi ,

    ,

    ,

    pi pi .

    () pi pi pi , :

    ( 4, . 2), pi , pi

    pi ,

    pipi

    pi pi , pi

    ( , 51). () 2, . 3, , pi ,

    :

    ,

    ,

    .

    pi , pi

    (ISGH). () pi pi pi pi , pi

    , pi pi .

    pi pi .

    () , pi pi pi pi

    pipi pi

    pi pi (" "). pi pi pi .

    , pi pi

    , o pi pi pipi pi pi . pi pipi,

    :

  • 38

    pi, pi pi

    pi (pi, pi.., ), pi pi , pi,

    pi.

    () , pi, pi.

    2.4 2.4.1 pi pi

    , pipipi (1983) (. 71-74, pi): "

    , pi

    , pipi, pi .

    pi:

    () pi pi pi ,

    . pi pi pi

    , pi

    pi pi . pi

    pi pi

    , pi pi

    , pi pi . pi

    pi .

    () pi pi , pi pi .

    pi ,

    . pi

    De jure belli ac pacis (pi pi ) pi de Groot (Grotius), pi .

    () pi pi pi

    .

    pi, pi pi pi

    , pi pi

    , , pi

    pi .

  • 39

    pi , pi .

    pi pipi pi

    pi , pi

    ,

    , pi pipi

    . pi

    pi pi .

    pi pi

    pi , pi pi

    , pi,

    pipi pi

    pi .

    , pi , pi

    pi

    pi ,

    pi pi

    pi pi .

    pi pi pi

    pi pi pi ,

    . 28 1, . 1, pi pi pi pi

    , pi

    pipi , pi pi

    . , ,

    pi pi

    pi, pi pi pi

    pi pi .

    pi

    pi ,

    pi, pi pi

    ,

    pi .

    . 28 1 . 1 , pi pi

    pi pi pi

    pi pi , pi

    .

    pi pi pipi pi

    .

  • 40

    pi pi , pipi

    pi pi

    pi pipi .

    , pi pi

    pi pi pi . pi,

    pi ,

    pi pi pi pi pi

    , pipi,

    pi pi, pi

    pi .

    , pi pi ,

    pi,

    pi , pi

    pi pi

    pi .

    , pipi

    (. pi pi pi , pi ), pi pi pi pipi

    pi, , pi

    .

    pi pi pi

    , pi pi

    pi . 28 1 . 1, pi pi

    . pi pi pi

    pi . 28 1 . 1."

  • 41

    2.4.2 pi () pi

    pi

    pi (international soft law), , pi . pi pi ,

    pi pi pi , pi

    pi pi .

    () : pi pi

    pi pi

    pi, pi ,

    pi pi pi ( pi ) pi pi fora . pi

    (General Agreement on Trade in Services, "GATS"), pi pi pi

    pi. 1 38 . pi, , ,

    (reports) pi fora (pi pipi pi pipi). fora:

    , pipi, ,

    ad hoc pi pipi pi pi ( children of crises),

    ,

    pi ,

    pi " pi pipi" (standard setting bodies, standard setters), pi pipi.

    pi pi fora pipi, standards. pi pi pipi pipi , pi

    pi pi.

    pi pi pi ad hoc pi pi.

  • 42

    pi , pipi pi

    pi pi , pi pi

    pi pi

    pipi.

    pi ( pi ) pi pipi :

    (recommendations), (core principles), pi (best practices).

    , pipi

    pi . pipi pi

    pi:

    () pi " " (regulatory benchmark) pi pi .

    () pi pi , pi ( pipi fora ):

    pi,

    pi pi pi

    ,

    pi pipi

    pi pi

    pi pi

    pi .

    () de facto pi .

    3. : 2 3.1 pi pi

    , pi (3) : pi, pi,

    pi,

    pi .

    2 pi- -

    (2006), . 3-8.

  • 43

    , .

    pi, ,

    ,

    lex mercatoria pipi .

    , pi, , pipi

    ,

    pi. pi pi pi

    ,

    pi pi .

    pipi pi pi

    .

    pi

    pi , pi pi, pi,

    fora pi pi .

    , pi pi , pi

    pi , pi

    pi

    .

    pi pi pi

    :

    pi

    pi ,

    pi

    (soft international economic law), ( pipi pi), pi pi ( pi pi pipi ).

    pi pi pi fora pi pipi

    pi pi

    . , pi

    , pi

    pi. pi

    pi ad hoc pi fora.

  • 44

    3.2 O fora pi

    .

    / pi pi . pi

    a fortiori fora pi . pi

    pi.

    , pi

    pi pi (/conditionality), pi

    pi pi,

    pi pi . pi pi,

    pi

    pi pi ,

    . ... pi pi pi

    , pi .

    pi pi pipi

    pi , pi

    pi:

    pi pipi

    ,

    pipi pi pi fora, pi pi

    ,

    pi ,

    pi

    pi pi

    pipi pi pi pi

    pi fora. pi, pi, pi

    pi pi pi

    (market discipline).

    3.3

    pi ,

    pi

    pipi pi pi

    pi. ,

    pi pi pi pi

    .

  • 45

    pi pi,

    pi pi

    pi pi pi

    pi. pi

    :

    , pi

    pi pi pi pi ,

    pi pi ( pi pi ), pi,

    pi,

    pi.

    pi, ,

    pi pi

    ( ) pi pipi pi pi

    pi. pipi,

    pi

    (uniform law). pipi, ,

    pi pi (1930) (1931), pi pi pi (1964). , pi

    pi pi

    (NGOs), pi , pi, , ( pipi pi) pi pi

    (lex mercatoria). pipi, : pi pi (International

    Chamber of Commerce, ICC) pi (Incoterms) pi ,

    pi pi pi

    pi (UNIDROIT), -pi pi

    (International Swap Dealers Association, ISDA) pi pi (derivative instruments).

  • 46

    4. () (pi ) pi , pi (pi) , pipi, pi

    pi pi pi

    pipi ( ). O pi :

    ,

    ,

    .

    (i) pi pi , pi

    pi , pi, :

    pipi

    ,

    pi pi

    ,

    pi pi pi

    .

    (ii) pi , pi pi pi , pi

    , pi ,

    .

    (iii) , , pi , pi pipi.

    .., 28 , pi pi pi pi

    ,

    " "

    pi "", pi

    .

    pipi . ,

    pipipi pi pipi .

    () ( ) pi - ""

    , " ".

  • 47

    (i) pi pi

    pi ( pi, ). (ii) pi pi ( ) pipi ( pi, pi pi pi pi

    pi ). pi 4 - 33 . pi pi

    pi . pipi pi

    .

    , pi, () 593/2008, , pi pi pi

    () 864/2007, , pi -

    .

  • 48

  • 49

    :

  • 50

  • 51

    1. pi ( pi ( ""), ), pi . pi , pi

    pi pi

    pi 27 . :

    pi ( ""), pi ( "")

    (pi ""). pi pi pi pi

    pi pi

    , , 2007, pi 1 2009.

    pi pi :

    () pi () 1957, pi 1 1958. pipi, , : 1. pi (1986), 2. (1992), pi pi

    pi ,

    3. (1999), 4. (2003), 5. (2009), pi "pi " ( pi ). () pipi pi .

    pi

    pi "pi" pi ,

    pi "pi" pi , pi

    pi pi pi .

  • 52

    pi 55 pi . , , pi pi 358 , pi , pi pi (pi, , pipi ) pi pi . pi pi pi ,

    :

    , pi 1-12 ( ),

    (4) (pi , pi 2),

    (pi 3), pi (pi 4), (pi 5).

    , , ( "") pi ,

    pi (pi 6).

  • 53

    pi pi , (1983) (. 76-77) : " pi pi , pi

    pi ' pipi

    pi pi

    pi. 18 pi 1951 , , , , pi

    pi

    . pi pi ,

    1955 pi , pi pi, 25 1957 , pi

    pi .

    pi , ,

    pi , pi pi pi 1 1973 , pi 1 1981 . pi pi

    , pi pi 28 1979 . 945/1979 pi pi

    , pi pi

    pi , pi

    pi pipi . 28 2. pi pi pi pi ' ,

    .

    pi pi pipi ."

    pi pi. 2 28 , pi , ( ).

  • 54

    2. 2.1 pi 2 , (4) pi pi :

    pi (pi , pi 2.2), (pi 2.3), (pi 2.4),

    pi pi , pi

    pi pi,

    ( 23-46). pi

    ( 2, pi. 6, ).

    pi " ". ( 5, pi. 2, ): " pi pi

    pi pi

    . pi pi

    ."

    pipi, pi pi

    pi :

    () pi ( 5, pi. 3, ): " pi pi pi ,

    (pipi ) pi pi pipi pi pi pi pi

    , pi pi pipi,

    pi , pi pipi

    , pi pipi ".

    () , ( 5, pi. 4, ): " pi (pipi ) pi pi pi ".

    pi pi pi

    . pipi,

    pi pi

    pipi .

  • 55

    2.2 pi , pi

    pi 3 :

    ,

    pi pi

    ,

    pi

    (" ", " "), pi pi

    pi,

    pi pi,

    pipi

    pi pi pi

    ,

    pi pi

    .

    pipi ,

    pi.

    pi pi pi

    ( 2, pi. 1, ).

    2.3

    pi 4 . pi. 1

    pi pi pipi pi

    . pipi :

    "

    pi .

    pi .

    pi pi

    pi " ( 2, pi. 2, ).

    , , ( 4, pi. 2, ): ,

    pi, pi pi ,

    , ,

    ,

    pi ,

  • 56

    pi,

    pi ,

    ,

    pi ,

    ,

    , ,

    pi

    , pi pi .

    pipi:

    () , pi , ,

    pi,

    pi

    ( 4, pi. 3, ). () pi pi ,

    pi, pi

    ( 4, pi. 4, ).

    2.4 (3) : () , pi pi . pi , pi

    , pi pi .

    ( 5, pi. 1, ). () pipi, pi:

    pi pi

    pi,

    pi ,

    pi

    pi ( 5, pi. 2, ). () , pi, pi .

    , pi ( 6 ): pi pi ,

    ,

  • 57

    pi,

    ,

    pi, pi pi, ,

    pi pi,

    .

    pi pi pi

    pi pi pi

    ( 2, pi. 5, ' , ).

    3. 3.1 pi . 13 :

    () 7: pi (pi , pi 3.2), pi (pi 3.3), (pi 3.4), pi pipi ( "pipi", pi 3.5), (pi 3.6), pi pi ( "", pi 3.7), , pi

    .

    pi

    pi , ,

    pi pi pipi

    pi.

    pi pi pi 14-17 19 . ,

    pi , pi

    223-287 . () pi pi , pipi :

    pipi,

    pipi .

    pi 300-307 .

  • 58

    pipi , pi pi

    pi ( 308 ), . pipi, pi .

    309 , pi pi , pi pi pi

    pi pi pipi pi

    pi

    ( ) . pi , pi , pi

    pi

    pi pi.

    3.2 pi ( 14 ) pi pi pi pipi pi

    . pi pi pi

    pi. pipi pi ,

    .

    pi pi 96 . pi 5 , , pi.

    pi pi pi

    .

    pi pipi:

    , pi , (pi , pi 4) ,

    pi

    ,

    pipi.

    3.3 pi ( 15 ) pi pi ,

    pi pi

    pi pi pi.

    pipi .

    pi pi pi

    , pi

    pipi. pi pipi

    pi pi .

  • 59

    pi pipi pi pi

    ( pi pi ) pi pi pi pi

    pi pipi. pi pipi, pi

    pi pi,

    pi pi , , pi,

    pi ,

    ( 18 ). pi ,

    pi . pipi pi

    , pi pi .

    pi pi

    , pi pi ,

    pi , pi .

    :

    pi pi

    ,

    pi

    pi

    pipi

    pi,

    pipi

    pi pi ,

    pi pi pi

    pi ,

    pipi pi pi

    pi pi ,

    pi pi pipi

    pi pi .

    3.4 ( 16 ) , pi pi ,

    . , pi,

    pi pipi pi pipi

    .

    , pi pi , pi 236 , pi ( ) pi pipi pi pipi, pi

    pi pipi .

    pipi pi ,

    pi pi.

  • 60

    pi pi pipi

    pipi .

    pi:

    pi, pi

    , pi

    pi

    pi pi pi

    pipi,

    pi, pi

    pi pi

    ,

    pi (EcoFin), pi pi

    pi pi .

    3.5 pipi ( 17 ) pipi pi

    pi pi . pi

    :

    pi

    pi pi ,

    pipi pi

    ,

    pipi pi,

    ,

    pi pipi ,

    pipi , pi

    pi pi pipi

    pi pipi ,

    pi pi pi

    pi .

    pipi, pipi pi

    , pipi pi. pi,

    pi pi pi

    pipi.

  • 61

    pipi, pi , pi

    , pi. pi, pi

    , pi

    pi pipi pi pi pi

    .

    pipi pi

    31 2014, pi pi pi pi , pi pi

    pipi pi pi ,

    pi pi . pi 1 2014, pipi pi pi pi, pi

    pi pipi (2/3) , pi pi

    .

    pipi pi pi

    pi pi pi pi pi

    pi .

    3.6 ( 19 )

    pi:

    ,

    ,

    .

    pi pi

    pi pi . pi pi

    .

    pi-

    pipi pi pi pi

    pi pi pipi 253 254 pi

    . pi pi

    .

    , pi:

    pi pi pi pi ,

    pipi,

    pi, pi , pi

    pi pi pi

    pi ,

    pi pi pipi pi pipi pi .

  • 62

    pipi pi

    pi pi

    pi pi pi .

    3.7 pi pi

    . , pi , pi pi. 1 7 pi , pi pi .

    pi pi pi pi

    pi

    . , :

    pipi ,

    ,

    pi pi pi,

    pi ( , pipi ),

    pi pi

    (pi , pi 4), , pi pi pi

    9 10 pi pipi pi

    ,

    pipi ( pi pi , 36 21 , pi

    ), pipi pi pi

    pi pi

    pi

    - ( 340 ).

  • 63

    4. pi 4.1 pi pi pipi

    , pi

    . pi 288-292 ( , , 2, 1), pi .

    , pi (5) pi :

    " pi" (legislative acts), 289 (pi , pi 4.2),

    " pi" (delegated acts), 290 (pi 4.3),

    " pi" (implementing acts), 291 (pi 4.4),

    , 292 (pi 4.5), .

    288 , pi , ,

    pi, .

    pi :

    () , pi ( 288, ). () pi pi, pi pi, pi pi

    ( ) (ibid, ). () pi pi , pi, (ibid, ). () (ibid, ).

    4.2 pi ( 289) pi , pi. 3 , pi pi :

    " ",

    " ".

  • 64

    () pi. 1 , , pi pi

    pi , pi pi

    pipi.

    () , , pi. 2 , ,

    pi:

    pi pi ,

    pi pi .

    , pi pi pi

    pipi, 17, pi. 2, . , pi. 4 289 lex specialis, pi:

    " pipi pi pi ,

    pi pi pi pi

    pi , pi pi

    pi pi pi pi".

    4.3 pi ( 290 ) pi, ,

    pi ( 290, pi. 3). pi (pi. 1, ), pi pi pipi, pi pipi:

    pi pipi

    pi,

    pi pi pipi

    pi.

    pi , pi pi,

    pi pipi pi,

    pi :

    () , pi, , , pi, pi

    , pi, pi, pi pi

    (pi. 1, ). () pipi pi pi (pi. 2, ). pipi pi :

    pi

    pi ,

  • 65

    pi pi pi

    , pi

    pi pi

    pi.

    pi :

    () . 39 pi pi , pi pipi:

    " pi pi pi

    pi pi

    pi, pi

    ".

    () 10 1093/2010/ pi pi pi, pi

    pipi pi

    " pipi" (regulatory technical standards) pi 290 . ' :

    10 () 1094/2010 pi pi

    pi ,

    () 1095/2010 pi pi

    .

    4.4 pi ( 291 ) pi. 1 , pi:

    " pi

    pi ".

    pi pipi

    pi , pipi, pipi

    , pi (pi. 4) " " pi

    pi (pi. 2). pi .

    pi. 2 pi , pi pi, ,

    , :

  • 66

    "pi pi pi

    pi pi

    pipi" (pi. 3).

    4.5 ( 292 )

    pi . :

    () , , pi ( ), pi:

    pi pi pipi, pipi

    pi pipi pi

    pi pi pipi ( ), , pi pi

    pi ( ). () pi, pi, pipi ,

    pipi pi ( ).

    4.6 pi pi pi

    pi pi ( pi pi pi "" pi pi

    pi ), , pi. 1 132 (pi pi 34 ). , (4) pi:

    ,

    pi,

    ,

    .

    pi, , ,

    pi, pi

    288 . pipi, ,

    pi ,

    pi :

    ,

    ,

    pi.

  • 67

    pi pi pi

    pi pi

    .

    pi pi

    pi pi

    pi, pi .

    5. 22 , pi pi , pi, pi,

    " ". pipi

    , pi pi

    , pi

    pi pi , pi

    . ,

    pi pi 22 326-334 , :

    () pi pi pipi pi (last resort solution), pi pi pi pi

    pi .

    : pi 2010 pi , pi pipi, pi pi

    pi . pi ,

    . pipi

    pi pi

    pi, pi pi pi

    pi pi pi

    EcoFin. () pi pi pi pi pi ( pi pipi 9). () pi pi:

    pi ,

    .

  • 68

    () pi pi .

    , , ,

    pi pipi pi

    .

    6. :

    6.1 pi pi pi 1999

    pi ( ) pi pi pi

    , 1992. pi pi ,

    pi pi ( , pi) pi pi

    pi

    pi, pi pi pipi

    pi .

    pi

    , pi pi

    , pi, pi:

    ( pi ) , pi

    ,

    pi pi,

    ( ) pi .

    pi , , pi

    pi pi pi ,

    , (pi, pi.., pi pi pi), pi pi, (, , pipi pi) pipi .

    , pi

    pi:

    pipi ( ), pi pi

    pi , ,

  • 69

    pi ( , pi, pi 3.7), , pi pi

    .

    pi, ,

    pi pi .

    , , pi pipi

    pipi:

    ( pi),

    ( ) pi pi pi

    pi .

    pi pi pi pi pi

    pipi pi ,

    () pi , pi

    pi .

    pi pi pi pi

    ,

    pi

    pi pi

    .

    pi :

    pi

    1971, , , 1979, pi

    ( ""), pi 31 1998, pi .

    pi

    1971 , ( pi) , pi pi

    , Bretton Woods. pi pi 1970, pi pi ,

    Bretton Woods , pi ,

    pi pi

    .

  • 70

    , pi , ,

    pi

    .

    6.2 pipi Delors 6.2.1 pi

    pi pi pi

    pi pi pi

    pi 1986, pi pi pi pipi

    1957. pipi pi - ,

    pi 1 1993. pipi -

    . -

    ( pi pi, pi pi) pi pi

    .

    , pi pi pi -

    . -

    -pi pi

    ,

    pi.

    pi pi-

    pi pi pi

    pi pipi pi ,

    pi .

    pi pi

    pi pi

    , pi pi

    pi , pi

    :

    pi pi

    pi pi pi ,

    pi pipi

    pi ,

    , pi pi pi

    pi pi

    pi pi .

  • 71

    1989, pi, pipi pi pi pi () pipi Jacques Delors ( pipi Delors), pi pipi pi pipi ,

    pi .

    pi , 1971, pipi Werner, , , pi pi

    pi pi.

    pi pi , pipi pi

    , pi pi pipi (4) pi:

    pi pi

    ,

    pi, pi pi

    pipi

    pi ( ), pi

    pi,

    , pi

    pi

    , pi .

    6.2.2 pi pi pi pipi Delors pi pi

    pi . pi

    , pi , , (. 25 26, ), pi .

    pi, pi pipi

    , , pi

    pi , pi pi

    . pi ,

    pi

    , , , (6) :

    (i) , pi pi, pi pi,

    pi ( pi) pi ,

  • 72

    (ii) pi pi pi , pipi pi

    , pi pi,

    (iii) pi pi,

    (iv) pi pi, ,

    (v) , pi pi,

    ,

    ,

    (vi) , pi pi

    pi, pi

    pipi pi pipi Delors, ,

    .

    6.3 pi 6.3.1 pi

    pi pi pipi Delors 1992 pi . , pi

    , pi

    , pi pi

    pi pi pi .

    pi, pi pi pi pipi

    :

    pi pi

    pi, pi

    pi (pi 6.3.2), ( ) pi

    , 1 1999.

    , pipi pi

    pi (6) .

  • 73

    6.3.2 pi pi pi pi

    pi

    pi

    , pi pi

    pi, pipi pi

    pipi:

    () pi pipi ( pi pi pi

    ) pi pi

    ( pi pipi ) ,

    ,

    . pi pi pipi

    pi ,

    pi pipi pi

    :

    pi, pi

    pi pi pi

    ,

    pi, pi

    , pi pi

    .

    , pi

    (pi pi) pi , pi

    pi pi,

    , pi .

    pi

    pi pipi

    pi

    pi . pi

    pi:

    (i) pi pi (coronation theory), pi

    pi pi:

    () pipi ,

    pi,

    pi

    .

  • 74

    (ii) , , pi pi pi

    pi

    pi pi.

    pi pi pi pi pi pi,

    pi pi

    (, pi, pi pipi pi pi).

    () pipi pi ,

    , pi pi

    pi pi ( pi ), ,

    pi . ,

    pi, , pi pi

    pi pi ,

    pipi

    . pi pipi

    2 , pi pi pi pi, ,

    " " ( "").

    6.4 6.4.1

    () pi pi

    pi. 2 4 , pi: "() ( ) pi , pi

    , ECU, pi ()". pi , pi,

    ( ) pi pi:

    ,

    ( ) pi pi pipi,

  • 75

    , pi

    pi pi

    pi .

    pi ,

    pi, pi

    pi .

    () pi pipi

    pipi,

    pi. ,

    pi pi,

    pi. pi, pi

    pi pi pi

    pi ,

    pi.

    , pi pi ,

    pi pi, pi pi pi

    pi ( ) pi conditio sine qua non .

    pi

    pi pi , pi

    pi, pi

    pi

    ( ) pi, : pi

    pi pi pi pi

    pi pi (pi pipi ) ,

    pipi

    .

    pi pi

    "pi pi".

    , pi ( pi ), pi pi ( ""). pi, pi

    , pi, , .

    pi , 8 , :

  • 76

    " pi pi

    pi ( ) ".

    6.4.2 pi. 1 4

    , pi: pi 2, pi () pi pi pi

    pi , ,

    .

    pi pipi ,

    pi ( pi pi pi) pi. pi, pipi pi,

    pi, pi pi,

    , pi

    . , pi pi

    pi pi pi pi pi

    .

    pi .

    pi,

    , , pi

    pi. , , pi

    pi, pi

    pi pi pi pi

    , pi pi pi :

    pi

    ( 99 ), pi pi

    pi

    pi ( 101-103) pi

    pi

    pi ( 101-104), pi ( 100).

  • 77

    6.5 pi pi, pi

    ( " "). , pi, pi

    pi pi pi pi , pi

    pi pi , pi

    .

    pi pi pi

    . pi ,

    pi (pi, , pi pi ) :

    pi pi ,

    pi pi pi .

  • 78

  • 79

    ()

    . (1983): pi , . . ,

    . (2008): , , ., ., pi ., ., . (2010): , , -

    . (2012): , & . . ,

    , . . (2011): pi : pi pi

    , ,

    , . . (2004): pi , . . ,

    . . (2012): , 6 pi .-. . pi, , -

    pi . (2007): , & . . ,

    pi . (1999): , & . . , pi, . (2009, pi pi): , ,

    pi . . (2000): pi, . . , -

    ., . (2011): pi , ,

    , . . (2009): , I, , . . , -

    pi, . (2006): PLUS ULTRA pi, . . ,

    , .. . . (2006): pi : pi , ,

    . (1995): Justi atque injusti scientia - pi , . . , -

    pipi . (2006): , . . , -

  • 80

    . (pi.) (2006): pi pi, . , . .

    ,

    , .. . . (2006): , pi (: .. . . ), . 1, , , . (2012): & : , ,

    , . (2002): pi, pipi, pi, pi B , . . , -

    , . (2011) (, pi): pi, .

    , . (2010): pi , pi